Cases & Deals

Sherwin-Williams persuades the Mississippi Supreme Court that plaintiff failed to prove injury from lead paint

Clients Sherwin-Williams Company, The

Jones Day successfully defended The Sherwin-Williams Company against a teenager's claim that he ingested Sherwin-Williams' lead paint as a toddler and was permanently injured. The Mississippi Supreme Court reversed a jury verdict for plaintiff in his hometown of Jefferson County. (The Jefferson County jury had awarded plaintiff substantially less than he requested, demonstrating the strength of Sherwin-Williams' evidence at trial.) The Supreme Court's majority held that plaintiff's medical experts had no scientifically reliable basis on which to say that his one-time, moderately elevated blood lead level injured him. Therefore, the trial court erred by permitting plaintiff's expert testimony. The concurring justices found that plaintiff's eyewitness testimony identifying Sherwin-Williams as the manufacturer and seller of the lead paint ingested by plaintiff was incredible. The Supreme Court rendered judgment for Sherwin-Williams.

The Sherwin-Williams Co. v. Trellvion, No. 2009-TS-01866 (Mississippi Supreme Court)

We use cookies to deliver our online services. Details of the cookies and other tracking technologies we use and instructions on how to disable them are set out in our Cookies Policy. By using this website you consent to our use of cookies.