General Contractors' Workers' Compensation Plan Bars Personal Injury Claims Against Subcontractor
On July 13, 2017, Houston's Fourteenth Court of Appeals in Berkel & Company Contractors, Inc. v. Lee, 2017 WL 2986856, reversed a $43.5 million jury verdict for a superintendent who lost a leg after a crane collapsed at a construction site. The court held that the Texas Workers' Compensation Act barred the plaintiff's recovery of common law damages and that the intentional conduct exception did not apply because there was insufficient evidence of intent.
The court first found that the workers' compensation bar applied to the plaintiff, who was employed by the general contractor, even though the defendant was a subcontractor, because the general contractor provided workers' compensation insurance for its subcontractors through a contractor-controlled insurance program, creating a deemed employee–employer relationship. The court then examined the standards for establishing intent through knowledge with substantial certainty. The court held that "an actor must have known that his conduct was substantially certain to result in specific consequences—i.e., in injury to a particular victim, or to someone in a small class of potential victims within a localized area."
Although the court found evidence that the defendant knew the crane's collapse was substantially certain and could have foreseen that the plaintiff might be nearby, that was not enough. The court held there was insufficient evidence of intent because there was no evidence the defendant knew the plaintiff's specific location or that the defendant knew the exact fall path of the equipment.
Importance of the Decision
The court's interpretation underscores the importance of closely examining owner- or contractor-controlled insurance programs anytime there is workplace injury or death, including where the employee may work for a subcontractor. Also, owners, subcontractors, and general contractors should closely examine these programs and the potential protections afforded at the contracting stage.
For further information, please contact your principal Firm representative or one of the lawyers listed below. General email messages may be sent using our "Contact Us" form, which can be found at www.jonesday.com/contactus/.
Nicole M. Perry
J. Laurens Wilkes
Jane W. Walker
Jones Day publications should not be construed as legal advice on any specific facts or circumstances. The contents are intended for general information purposes only and may not be quoted or referred to in any other publication or proceeding without the prior written consent of the Firm, to be given or withheld at our discretion. To request reprint permission for any of our publications, please use our "Contact Us" form, which can be found on our website at www.jonesday.com. The mailing of this publication is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. The views set forth herein are the personal views of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Firm.